15 Minutes With the Touchscreen MacBook Pro and VoiceOver: Is It a Good Buy for Blind Users?
After years of rumours, Apple has finally done it: the Mac has a touchscreen. The new MacBook Pro with PROLED XDR Display was unveiled in late October, and I recently got about 15 minutes of hands-on time with it. Of course I turned VoiceOver on straight away, because I had one big question: would this finally give blind Mac users an iPad-style experience on a laptop?
Short answer: not yet. But let's start with what's new.
What's New
The headline feature is the display. Apple calls it PROLED XDR, and it uses the same tandem OLED technology found in the iPad Pro, which stacks two OLED layers for extra brightness. Reviewers rave about true blacks, very high brightness and excellent HDR. That doesn't mean much to me personally, but it's worth knowing if you have low vision or share the machine with sighted family members.
The bigger change for everyone is touch. For the first time, you can reach up and touch a Mac's screen to tap buttons, scroll, drag things around and pinch to zoom. Apple sees touch as an extra, not a replacement for the keyboard and trackpad.
Other highlights:
Available in 14-inch and 16-inch sizes, starting at $2,899
M5 Pro and M5 Max chips
Up to 24 hours of battery life
Thinner and lighter than before
Three Thunderbolt 5 ports, HDMI and an SD card slot
An iPhone-style Dynamic Island replacing the notch
First Impressions: Thin, Light and a Little Hollow
The first thing I noticed when I picked it up was how surprisingly thin and light it is. Apple has clearly worked hard on that.
But the more I held it, the more something felt off. The whole body feels empty, like a hollow shell. I understand that everything inside is miniaturised these days, but there's a point where thin and light starts to feel fragile and cheap. For a laptop starting at $2,899, I expected it to feel more solid in the hands.
What I Was Hoping For
If you use an iPhone or iPad, you know how natural VoiceOver feels on a touchscreen. You drag your finger across the glass and VoiceOver tells you exactly what's under it. You build a mental map of where things are on the screen. Double-tap to activate, and you're done.
I walked in hoping the MacBook Pro's touchscreen would work the same way with VoiceOver on: touch the screen, hear what's there, and explore the layout directly. That would have been a real game changer for blind Mac users.
What It Actually Does
It doesn't work like an iPad at all. With VoiceOver on, the touchscreen behaves exactly like the Trackpad Commander that's been on the Mac for years. If you haven't used it, the Trackpad Commander lets you control VoiceOver with iOS-style gestures on the trackpad: swipe right or left to move between items, double-tap to activate, and so on.
On the new MacBook Pro, the screen does exactly that, and nothing more. I couldn't find any difference between using the gestures on the screen and using them on the trackpad. You can't touch an icon and hear what it is. There's no direct exploration of what's on the display. In practice, the glass is just a second, bigger trackpad.
Here's one example I found really telling: the Dock. If you try to use the screen as a real touchscreen and find the Dock with your finger, you run into trouble straight away. The Dock sits so low, right down by the hinge, that touching and swiping along it is very awkward. In the end, it was much easier to jump to the Dock with the usual VoiceOver hotkey, then swipe left and right on the trackpad, or use the arrow keys, to pick what I wanted.
Is It Useful for Blind Users?
Honestly, no. For blind people, this is very disappointing news. The screen is completely useless for us and adds nothing to what we already use on a regular Mac: the Trackpad Commander and hotkeys with the VoiceOver modifier. If you already use the Trackpad Commander, you gain nothing you didn't have before. If you rely on keyboard commands, which most experienced Mac VoiceOver users do, you'll likely never touch the screen at all.
It's a bit of a shame. Apple already has one of the best touchscreen screen readers in the world on the iPhone and iPad. Bringing that experience to a touchscreen Mac seems like the obvious next step, and it would make macOS far more approachable for blind people who grew up on iOS.
To be fair, this is the first touchscreen Mac, and I only had 15 minutes with it. Apple could improve this with a software update. I really hope it does.
Bottom Line
The new MacBook Pro is a big step for the Mac, but for VoiceOver users the touchscreen is, for now, just the Trackpad Commander on a different surface. If you're blind and thinking about upgrading, don't buy it for the touchscreen. Buy it for the performance and battery life if you need them, and keep your fingers crossed for a future update that brings true iPad-style VoiceOver to the Mac.
Have you tried it yourself? Let me know what you think.
Sources
Apple Newsroom: Apple unveils MacBook Pro with PROLED XDR Display
MacRumors: Hands-On With Apple's New OLED Touchscreen MacBook Pro
Cult of Mac: Why Apple built a touchscreen into the OLED MacBook Pro
Engadget: Apple's redesigned MacBook Pro has an OLED touchscreen
GSMArena: Apple announces new MacBook Pro models with OLED and touchscreen
Comments