Hands-On: The Google Home Speaker Isn't the Gemini Blind Users Need
I bought the Google Home Speaker, Google's new smart speaker and the successor to its Nest speakers, for one simple reason: I wanted Gemini always on and hands-free in my home, working just like it does on my phone. Reader, that is not what I got.
Setup with VoiceOver: mostly painless
To get started, you download the Google Home app on your iPhone. Good news first: setup is mostly VoiceOver accessible. I'd say about 95% of it was easy to do on my own, which, by smart home standards, is practically a miracle.
The other 5%? A few screens weren't very VoiceOver friendly, so at certain points I had to call in a human with working eyeballs. Close, Google. So close.
The voice recognition setup, which teaches the speaker to know your voice and give you your personal information, was very VoiceOver friendly. No problems there at all. It knows who I am. It just can't do much about it, but we'll get to that.
Sound and hardware: the hidden treasure
The sound quality isn't as good as a mid-range Amazon Echo, but it's not bad either. Think pleasant kitchen radio, not concert hall. There's also a switch on the back that turns the microphone on and off, which is handy when you'd like a little privacy from your speaker.
Then there are the buttons. Or, as I like to call them, the hidden treasure. They're buried somewhere under the fabric of this cute little sphere, and finding them by touch feels like a game of hide-and-seek where the other player never comes out. Google's solution, according to reviews like Tom's Guide's, is that when you tap the top, two little lights turn on to show you where the volume buttons are. How thoughtful. I'll have to take their word for it, because those lights are doing absolutely nothing for me. So, to be clear: the controls on a speaker you're supposed to use with your voice were designed for your eyes. Not exactly blind friendly.
But honestly, I didn't buy this speaker for music or sound quality. I bought it for the brain. And that's where things get interesting.
This isn't the Gemini you know
Here's the real problem. The speaker doesn't give you the full Gemini, the one you get in the Gemini app on your phone or running always on on an Android tablet. Instead, you get Gemini for Home, which is a bit like ordering a steak and getting the drawing of a steak. Same name, much less to chew on.
If you want an always-on AI that works like the Gemini iOS app, where you can ask it to do real tasks for you, you're out of luck. I couldn't get it to read my email, and I couldn't get it to send one either. For me, that was the deal breaker.
I'm not the only one
Before you think it's just me and my special talent for breaking gadgets: reviewers and users have been frustrated with Gemini for Home too. Gizmodo found that it sometimes ignores questions completely, even when the light shows it's listening. Android Authority says it sometimes refuses to carry out rather basic commands, and that other users have reported the same thing. TechRadar reported on a user whose speaker couldn't answer a question as simple as how long to cook a sweet potato, even after resetting their devices four times. Four times. For a sweet potato.
Most of those complaints are about reliability. My problem goes further: even when it works perfectly, Gemini for Home simply can't do many of the things the Gemini app can.
My verdict
The way it is today, I don't see the Google Home Speaker as an accessibility tool. Setup is mostly accessible, the sound is fine, and it looks lovely, or so I'm told. But the watered-down Gemini for Home can't handle the kinds of tasks that make Gemini so useful for blind people.
If what you want is a hands-free Gemini that can actually get things done, an Android tablet running the full Gemini app is the better choice for now. It's less cute, but it actually does the job.
Do you use a Google Home Speaker with VoiceOver or TalkBack? Has yours found its buttons yet? Tell me how it's going in the comments, or contact me.
Comments