What Blind Riders Are Saying About Uber Ahead of Tonight's Town Hall
Tonight, the NFB and Uber are holding a town hall for blind riders. Before you join, it helps to know what the community has been saying. The complaints fall into two main groups: the app itself, and what happens when the car shows up.
The app: accessible on paper, patchy in practice
Uber says its web and mobile apps are accessible with VoiceOver and TalkBack, and plenty of blind riders use it every day. But testers keep finding gaps. One accessibility review found the app wasn't consistently built for VoiceOver: images were missing alt text, the focus order wasn't logical, and some features weren't available to the screen reader at all. A separate case study points to trouble navigating with VoiceOver and TalkBack, and to inaccessible map features for picking pickup and drop-off spots. If you can't check where the pin is, you can end up waiting on the wrong corner.
Uber does fix problems, but often only after riders complain. A few years ago, blind riders couldn't reliably rate their driver with VoiceOver. You'd try to give 5 stars, and the app might record fewer by mistake. One AccessWorld writer got so worried about unfairly hurting good drivers that she started leaving a comment with every rating, explaining that anything under 5 stars was the app's fault, not the driver's. Later updates fixed that particular issue.
Drivers and guide dogs: the bigger problem
For many blind riders, the biggest complaint has nothing to do with the app. Blind and low-vision riders with service dogs have reported rides being canceled after the driver saw their dog. That happens even though Uber's own policy says drivers are required by law to transport riders traveling with service animals. It has also ended up in court: individuals and disability rights organizations have sued Uber and Lyft, alleging violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act.
My own experience
The map problem is real for me too. Choosing or checking a pickup spot on the map just doesn't work well with VoiceOver or TalkBack. To be fair, making a map truly accessible is a hard problem, so I don't expect a quick fix.
The cancellations are worse than the map. I've had many, many drivers cancel after I told them I'm blind and use a white cane. I don't have a guide dog. My guess is that some drivers assume I'll be "high maintenance" and don't know what to do, and others assume I have a dog and don't want it in their car. Either way, being honest about my disability gets me stranded.
What about driver training?
Uber does have a guide for drivers on serving riders with disabilities. What I don't know is whether drivers actually have to complete it, or if it's just there for anyone who wants to read it. If it's optional, that could explain a lot.
Questions worth asking tonight
Is disability training required for every driver, or optional?
What happens to a driver who cancels on a blind rider, with or without a guide dog?
Is there a plan to make pickup and drop-off selection work properly with screen readers?
Have you had the same problems with Uber? Leave a comment below, or contact me.
Comments